|
Post by Cams on Apr 7, 2016 12:40:20 GMT
I thought some of you would enjoy reading the thread I put together for the AGF about the journey that led me to get my beautiful Kim Walker SJ. The Seed is SownI played a Kim Walker guitar in 2005 for five minutes. It was a 'Nick Lucas' that belonged to my friend John Thomas. The trebles on that guitar were like nothing I had experienced ever before. At that time, I was in Georgia at Little Brother's Acoustic Jam where some of the best guitars in the country and their owners/builders were gathered together for the weekend. The Kim Walker stood out head and shoulders above the other guitars at the jam. Those five minutes were enough for me to know that there was a Kim Walker guitar in my future. I put my name down on the list, paid the deposit and the wait began. Kim got in touch in November 2013 to say my slot had rolled around. What did I do in the interim? Background and ResearchAt deposit time, I owned a guitar made by German luthier Heiner Dreizehnter that I absolutely loved, and still do. That guitar was one of those serendipitous lucky finds for which I shall forever be grateful. It was my reference model for what I liked in a good guitar. I once bought a Gibson J200 that blew my socks off; I owned it for about half an hour. It was in a local shop and had haunted me for a few months. I finally decided to bring it home then noticed that it had a big crack across the bridge. The shop naturally wanted me to keep it and were going to have it repaired, but weren't offering any discount and so I returned it for a refund. I've always kinda regretted that. Bear with me as this is an important data point for the Walker story. A while later I was in London and popped in to a guitar shop to try their extensive range of Lakewoods. My first decent acoustic was a cedar/mahogany Lakewood M model and I always liked the brand. I wasn't in there long before I spotted a Gibson J150. I tried it and bought it in a moment of madness, thinking it would be a substitute for the J200 that got away. It wasn't. I ended up selling it and buying a Brook Tamar 27" baritone because, at that time, I was playing in low C a lot and thought that the longer scale guitar would be great for that. It wasn't. Lovely guitar in every way, but not a keeper. That was the guitar I sold to fund the Dreizehnter. Good move! Dreadnought?I bought a mahogany Guild dread on eBay for playing in pub sessions, but never really got on with it well and sold it. Did that mean that a dread wasn't for me? Hmmm. Once I got my name on Kim's list, I got into flatpicking in quite a big way. I spent two weeks at Steve Kaufman's Kamp and got to try countless D18s, D28s, Collings, Santa Cruz etc. Maybe there was more to this dreadnought thing than I thought! I had my Dreizehnter with me and it more than cut the mustard, but I needed to know if a good dreadnought would suit me, and whether that would be a good choice for my Walker with the time came. Santa CruzI knew of Santa Cruz's pedigree as Little Brother was a big fan of their Southern Jumbo model. It was at the jam in Georgia where I won a raffle. The prize? A voucher from my pal Kelvyn who just happened to be a Santa Cruz dealer. The voucher gave the winner their choice of Santa Cruz at cost price with no dealer's markup. At that time, I was moderator on the Santa Cruz players' forum. I went to a trade show in Germany where Santa Cruz founder Richard Hoover just happened to be working the stall. I sat down with him over a cup of coffee and he offered, as a thank you, to build me a guitar with some of his 'silver ghost' Sitka and old-growth Cuban mahogany at a very good price. How could I refuse? I chose the Vintage Artist model, mainly because it was described as a D18 equivalent and I'm a sucker for herringbone. The plan with the Santa Cruz initially was to own a good dreadnought to see how I liked it and then sell it on and have a very good chance of recouping my cost thanks to the premium woods and the initial purchase price. But, d'you know what? It turns out that I love that guitar way too much to let it go! It became my primary guitar for gigs and sessions and it's now a fully fledged keeper. So, that's a bit of background. The next instalment will cover the thought processes behind choosing what style of guitar for Kim to build and how we came up with what we did.
|
|
|
Post by Cams on Apr 7, 2016 12:43:16 GMT
Deciding on a styleI've had three guitars that I would consider great: the Gibson J200, Dreizehnter Model A and Santa Cruz VA. What do I want my Walker to be? A fingerstyle miracle? A bluegrass jam-busting flatpicker? The best DADGAD rhythm guitar ever made? And am I going to keep it at home or take it out? Do I care about appointments? I thought that after 9 years of being on the list and having the build slot constantly on my radar, I'd have zeroed in on exactly what I wanted my Walker to be. But I wasn't even close. All I could think about were the fat trebles; that's what haunted my dreams. The Model AIf had to grab a guitar in a fire, it would've been the Dreizehnter Model A. So, it made sense to use its pros and cons to help me come up with a Walker model. I saw it at a two-day guitar show in Germany at a time in my playing career when I hadn't tried very many good guitars. During those two days I played literally dozens of guitars: countless Martins and Gibsons, both new and vintage; Lowdens and Avalons; more guitars in fact than I can remember. Heiner had the Model A on his display stand in pride of place. Well, it was rather attractive and it really stood out from the crowd with its blackwood top. But a blackwood top? Really? That shouldn't work, right? Back and sides sure, but a top? Heiner offered it to me to play so I thought I'd humour him and give it a try. But wait... That can't be right? This thing sounds amazing! I sat with it for a while and couldn't believe what I was hearing. I handed it back and walked away. I went back to my wandering round the hall, trying this and trying that until my ears had reached saturation point and I wasn't really hearing much of a difference between guitars anymore. I went back to Heiner's stand and tried the Model A again. It still had it! Even when I had had enough acoustic guitar for the day, that guitar still did it for me like no guitar had since the J200-that-got-away. You're probably thinking that I bought it, aren't you? Well, I didn't. It just wasn't on the cards. I went home and tried to forget about it. But I couldn't. So two months later I got in touch with Heiner to see if he still had it, and thankfully he did. So it came to me in December 2003. What is it that I love so much about that guitar? Well, it was the bass that grabbed me first. I do love a good rumble, you know, the kind that you can feel in your chest when you play. I can play the most tender of fingerstyle tunes on that guitar and literally bring tears to my eyes with its tone. I can flatpick fiddle tunes on it with a heavy Red Bear pick and not get lost in the mix. I know that because I took it to Kaufman's Acoustic Kamp for two weeks in 2005. It works well in DADGAD and even low C. It's great for rhythm and singer songwriter stuff. So, what's wrong with it? Well, to be honest, not much. It could use a bit more volume for acoustic jams. The one thing I would change would be the tone of the B string; it's a little thin. So I guess what I'm looking for is an all rounder with more volume, fatter trebles and perhaps a cutaway as I'm getting more adventurous with the dusty end of the fingerboard these days! Talking with KimI never actually spoke to Kim on the phone until I was arranging my travel to go and pick up the SJ. The specs were all nailed down by email. I sent Kim links to videos and audio recordings I'd made with my Model A and wrote a long email outlining what I liked and didn't like in a guitar. I had the idea in my mind that the SJ would be the model to suit my requirement of a good all rounder, but I waited to see what Kim would suggest before I mentioned that to him. And yes, he did suggest the SJ. I thought he might have gone with mahogany, and I did consider blackwood or koa, but I guess he doesn't work with these woods much or maybe he didn't think they would fit the bill. I'm not sure. It can be a difficult thing discussing tone with a common vocabulary, which is why my videos and audio recordings helped Kim I think. It was also nice that John Thomas just happens to have an Adirondack/maple SJ, so I was able to talk to him about his and make my decision. Kim said that combo would give me a warm fat tone and who doesn't want that?! Next instalment: Travel and first impressions...
|
|
|
Post by Cams on Apr 7, 2016 12:44:00 GMT
Details and Completion
I made the decision quite early on in the build that I wanted to go and pick the guitar up in person. I wasn't sure whether I'd be able to afford the time or flights when completion date rolled around. I'd just have to wait and see.
I made international payments through the RBS spread out over a year or so and the exchange rate was in my favour and going in the right direction. I did start to worry when it looked like Scotland might actually take independence in the referendum as I was pretty sure that that would weaken the GBP against the USD and my last payment was still pending! Not that that's of much interest in a guitar build thread, but I add it just in case anyone else considering an international build hasn't considered this. Scotland in fact didn't win independence, but it was a small margin!
Oh, and the case. I haven't mentioned the case, have I? Kim gave me options:
I went with the Hoffee, having seen Tim May's when he was over playing in Scotland in 2014. Kim was right - it is awesome! I do own a Calton and it's a heavy beast of a case. The Hoffee is way nicer.
The final decision was the pick-up. I do play out - more on that later. I asked Kim if he would be happy installing a pick-up and what he would recommend, but he seemed hesitant and said nobody ever really asks for that. I was quite surprised to hear that. My go to pick-up has been David Enke's PUTW and I did consider that, but after a bunch of research, I decided to try the Baggs Lyric. Meanwhile Kim had been over on Doug Young's pick-up page and was quite impressed with just how far the technology has come since he last looked at pick-ups. I ordered the Lyric from Sweetwater and had it shipped to Kim's address.
I went with the default medium tall fretwire on Kim's recommendations - I hadn't even considered being asked about fretwire to be honest.
I got an email from Kim to say that the guitar was ready and he was happy to hold onto it until I made the final payment and could get out there. This was tough, knowing my guitar was ready in one country and I in another! Getting away from work around Christmas was just not on the cards – I run a Post Office, so I was looking at early in the year. I did look at shipping options, but I really didn't want to go down that route if possible. So I liaised with Kim and John Thomas and booked flights for February.
And we're off...
|
|
|
Post by Cams on Apr 7, 2016 12:44:36 GMT
First ImpressionsI arrived in Boston on a cold February afternoon. I was a little tired, but the excitement of being in America again was bubbling in my tummy and stepping out of the airport into the freezing temperatures was wonderful. I made my way to the train station to catch the Amtrak to Mystic CT and had the most amazing train ride, watching the snowy landscape's passing by and listening to Dark Side of the Moon on my good headphones. I got into Mystic around teatime and the light was amazing as the sun was going down. I waited about 10 minutes for Kim to come and pick me up and finally got to meet the man in person and shake his hand. Kim took me to North Stonington by the scenic route, including a trip down to the seashore to look out over Long Island Sound and it was a great moment. We got to Kim's and his wife Dianna was there to greet me and show me to my room where I could dump my bags. Then, without further ado, Kim invited me downstairs to his workshop to meet my SJ. I'd gone for the purple Hoffee case and there it was, sitting on the bench waiting for me. I opened up the case and first laid eyes on my SJ. That new guitar smell wafted up to my nostrils and I breathed it in, eyes filming over with tears that this moment was finally here after almost 10 years. I had of course gone over this moment in my head countless times and considered what I was going to play first, but all that went right out of my head and I'm sorry to say that I can't even remember now what I played first. The thing that struck me initially on picking up the guitar was the same thing that still strikes me every time I pull it off its wall hanger or out of its case, and that is the feel of the five-piece neck and the finish. It feels quite unlike any other guitar I've ever held. There is a weight to it, a feeling of solidity that lets me know that I'm holding something unique and valuable. Kim had strung it with GHS True Mediums and the action was a little high as per my request. This was to be a flatpicking and rhythm guitar first and foremost. We had never really discussed neck profile other than to say that I had reasonably big hands and didn't like anything too thin or too fat. Not really much for a luthier to go on I guess, so I was fortunate that I found the neck very comfortable. It's too fat for my sliding capo to be of much use, but I wouldn't put it on there anyway as it's not too kind to the finish on a guitar neck. It stays on my Santa Cruz VA that has already been subjected to a fair amount of play wear. I'd gone with a 1-3/4" nut and generous spacing at the saddle and, when I started playing the instrument, I began to fear that it was a bit too generous. It made the whole guitar play like it had a 1-13/16 nut. And, to be honest, I was a little travel weary and, with Kim watching over my shoulder, it was difficult for me to find some honest feelings about the tone and playability. I played several pieces, some folk with a thumbpick in standard and dropped D, some rhythm and flatpicking and some fingerstyle in standard and DADGAD. Then we put it back in its case and went back upstairs for some food and to get to know each other a bit better. I wasn't sure how I felt at that time, so I let it go and decided to give myself some time to adjust. To be honest, I wish I'd kept better notes of the details as, sitting here one year on, I'm struggling to remember much of what we did and talked about that evening. I did write in my diary that I went to bed at 8 p.m. local time and slept right through till 7 the next morning. Take that, jet lag! A thing that you probably don't know about Kim is that he's not only one of the world's finest luthiers, he also makes a darn fine cup of coffee. He and I share a love of the AeroPress method and I got a really useful tip from him that I'm using to this day. See the paper filters? You can rinse them and reuse them at least twice! For some reason this had never crossed my mind, so I can now put the savings I'm making towards another guitar, right? Of course! Dianne made us a really good breakfast, and I mean really good - Spanish omelette, crispy bacon, hot sauce and home made jams with endless coffee, ground from freshly-roasted beans and served in a clay mug. It was and remains one of the best breakfasts I've ever had. Before visiting Kim, he'd sent me a link to a radio show featuring Paul Asbell talking about and playing his new Kim Walker guitar. That kind of got me thinking about just what fine players Kim must have had visit and made me a bit hesitant to play my guitar in his company. I know, I know, that's just silly, right? But it was there nevertheless. I'm pleased to say that it didn't last very long though. After that wonderful breakfast, I brought the SJ up to the lounge and Kim went off to do whatever it is that Kim does on a wintery Saturday morning. Dianna sat at the table and relaxed and I sat by the fire playing the SJ for a good three hours. I soon began to lose myself and really get a feel for how this guitar played and what it had to offer. I had worked on a few of El McMeen's tunes in CGDGAD and took my time over them, giving the guitar a chance to savour the notes of My Mary of the Curling Hair, the Humors of Ballyloughlin, Hector the Hero and the Mist-Covered Mountains of Home. Despite the fact that this was to be a flatpicking guitar, it works really well with fingerstyle too. Bonus! The most memorable moment for me of that morning was playing a fingerstyle arrangement of Auld Lang Syne. It's one of my own arrangements that I'd come up with the previous December for our Hogmanay gig with the Arran Ceilidh Band. I'd arranged it actually on the afternoon of Hogmanay, played it that night and then not really gone back to it. Well, it is traditionally a song for new year after all. I didn't want to lose the arrangement, so I figured what better time than right now to try and get it back again. It didn't take long I'm pleased to say and I must've played it through a dozen times. It was a moment. Dianna then commented on how lovely it was to be listening to my playing, like her own personal concert! Those three first hours with my new guitar was one of the best experiences I've had in all my playing career. It was a real getting-to-know-you moment for us both, trying all the songs and tunes I could remember from my repertoire, with one thing leading to another thing and songs coming to mind. It's nice to be writing this a year later and thinking back to just how special that time was and I can see now that making the decision to go and pick up the guitar in person was the right thing to do, even if it meant a transatlantic flight for a weekend. If anyone reading this has a custom guitar build on the horizon and can manage to pick up the guitar in person from the luthier, I would wholeheartedly recommend that you do that. It's seriously worth it! So that was the first meeting and my first impressions. Next up is how we spent the afternoon and evening on an already memorable day.
|
|
|
Post by Cams on Apr 7, 2016 12:45:28 GMT
The afternoon and eveningJohn Thomas came over for lunch, at least he *said* he was coming over for lunch, but with a newly minted SJ in the living room, I think he might just have had an ulterior motive! We played for a bit then sat down to a fantastic lunch of gumbo of crusty bread. It was absolutely delicious and, followed of course by some more fine coffee. Then we headed down stairs to Kim's workshop. Fellow UK picker Nigel had not one, but two new Kim Walker guitars waiting to be picked up and he'd given me strict instructions to try them and report back. Well, it was a tough assignment but I was happy to oblige. He had a cocobolo OM and a 000 in jaguar mahogany. The OM was lush, but the 000 was absolutely stellar. That Kim Walker knows how to build a guitar, that's for sure! John had brought over his AER acoustic amp and we played around with the Lyric pickup in my SJ, but I hadn't brought any of my preamps and so I knew I would be able to tweak it and hopefully get some good tone for playing out. And then it was time to go. We said our goodbyes to Kim and Dianna and hopped into John's car for the drive to John's place. I hadn't seen John for 10 years so we had some catching up to do. We got there around tea time and chilled for a bit in the conservatory and then it was time to be introduced to some fine old guitars from John's collection, including two banner Gibson guitars from the WW2 era and, of course, John's three Kim Walker guitars. I was reacquainted with the guitar that started this whole thing off 10 years ago, John's 'Nick Walker'. After some pickin', it was time for some eatin' and we went out for a fine meal at John's local with John and his good lady and had a wonderful meal. I'm always bowled over by the hospitality of fellow players I've visited in the USA. After our meal it was back to John's for some more playing of fine instruments. One of my favourite songs to play is Springsteen's Ghost of Tom Joad, partly because Grapes of Wrath is one of my all-time favourite novels. I sat in John's conservatory and played that song on one of his old banner Gibsons and it was a special moment. The fingerpicking of the song sat so sweetly on that guitar and its age and my location and the friendship all tied together into an unforgettable moment for me. And then my journey was over and it was time to head home. I had booked with British Airways after checking their cabin baggage policy and measuring it against my Hoffee case. And d'you know what? The BA staff could not have been more helpful or accommodating. They allowed me to board first and make sure I got my case in the overhead, not only on the international leg but also the connecting flight from London Heathrow to Glasgow. And so I made my weary way home back to the Isle of Arran, ready to introduce my new Kim Walker SJ to my friends and family. HoneymoonThe initial euphoria probably lasted about a month. It just so happened that we were making a CD for the Arran Ceilidh Band at the the time and I hadn't yet recorded my version of Tony McManus's Ye Banks & Braes yet. So I got to use the Walker for that particular track. Unfortunately, the sound engineer we were using doesn't like using mics for acoustic guitar so we used the a DI into the desk—remember the guitar is equipped with a Baggs Lyric. Nevertheless, I was pleased to be able to use the Walker on the new CD. https%3A//soundcloud.com/cams-campbell/ye-banks-braesMy pal and bandmate Donal (on fiddle on Ye Banks above) plays guitar too and he thought I was off my head paying so much for a guitar. I don't think he really believed it could be all that much better than what I already had. Then he played it one night after a gig and his jaw dropped. It was rather a good feeling actually! And so, my SJ was at home, the one I'd waited 10 years for. Did I like it as much as I knew I should? Did the anticipation match the reality? Big questions. I found myself having doubts after the first couple of months. You see, what was happening was that I was going out to play gigs with my Santa Cruz and Dreizehnter, two or three a week, and having no time to play at home. One night I had some time, I sat in the living room and played one of my favourite fingerstyle pieces on the SJ and on the Dreizehnter Model A. My wife was at her computer with her back to me and I asked her not to turn around, just to listen and tell me which one she preferred. Guess what? She preferred the Model A and was surprised because she was sure she'd picked the Walker. That was disappointing for me, but, to be honest, I thought the same. I would equate it to a pair of shoes you've had for a while and then you get a new pair that are lovely and expensive and shiny and, well, new. I needed to spend time with the Walker, let it loosen up a bit and show me what it could do. That wasn't going to happen without playing it, so I made the decision to start taking it out to gigs for the bluegrass band and use it exclusively for that. And that's what I did. I played it plugged in at least once a week in our bluegrass band, so it was getting a good work out with a heavy-gauge Red Bear pick, playing rhythm and flatpicked breaks. It was then that I noticed its buzzing. It had come from a rather dry environment to Scotland, where the RH is often as high as 80%. Not sure why that should cause buzzing - I would have expected the opposite. And so began the neck tweaks. Kim was kind enough to provide a Stewmac Allen key to get to the truss rod and, after confirming with Kim what sort of action I should be taking, I began the process of adjusting the neck relief bit-by-bit. Kim also provides two saddles with his guitar: one tall, one not so tall. It's the little things! It took a few weeks of trial and error, but I eventually got there with the neck relief and saddle height to where I like it. Not long after getting the guitar, I started lessons with Bryan Sutton on ArtistWorks and that's been great on the Walker. Tone is foremost in Bryan's lesson plan and I've been working on my technique and tone, using the Walker to practice on and work on my Video Exchanges. Here's Whiskey before Breakfast. It's now over a year since I brought the SJ home with me. I still take it out to my weekly bluegrass band gigs and I'm sure that it was making the decision to do that that helped me bond with the instrument. I'm not sure how that bond would've formed if I hadn't made that decision. I did have some moments when I wasn't quite sure that it was all that I'd hoped it would be, but as I played it more and more, the bond began to form and it felt comfortable. As for the tone, it's taken about a year for the top to start to open up and the difference is stark. After 20 minutes of playing time, it starts to hit its stride and the trebles are just like they were when I first played John Thomas's guitar, thick and bright and wonderful. I just had a weekend away at a guitar gathering in an English country manor and I spent a good 90 mins jamming with my plucky dip partner in the foyer beyond the main entrance and the acoustics in that part of the building were amazing. That Walker guitar sang! So, that's the story so far. Hope you liked it. I'll conclude by saying that my name is back on Kim's list. That should tell you something!
|
|
|
Post by Cams on Apr 7, 2016 12:46:27 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Cams on Apr 7, 2016 12:48:18 GMT
And finally, here's my favourite guitar player playing my favourite guitar at my house!
|
|
Martin
Administrator
Posts: 11,994
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"http://mandocello.org/lytebox/images/adirondack.jpg","color":""}
Mini-Profile Name Color: 0a530b
Mini-Profile Text Color: 4f3517
|
Post by Martin on Apr 7, 2016 13:06:33 GMT
Great read, Cams, thanks for posting. Gorgeous looking guitar too, and quite a decent personal demo at the end too!
|
|
ocarolan
Global Moderator
CURMUDGEONLY OLD GIT (leader - to join, just ask!)
Posts: 35,723
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"","color":"c0cfe1"}
Mini-Profile Name Color: 182a3f
Mini-Profile Text Color: 733a1c
|
Post by ocarolan on Apr 7, 2016 13:23:27 GMT
Superb posts Cams - very much enjoyed reading and listening - thanks! It's a tiny detail, but I really like the shot of the back of the headstock with its elegant little notch in the top. Keith
|
|
|
Post by Cams on Apr 7, 2016 13:31:48 GMT
I still get that feeling of quality when I pick up the Walker. It oozes class. Kim's attention to detail is impeccable. And Martin, I'd recommend that anyone get Tony McManus round to play their new guitars for them! An experience not to be missed!
|
|
Riverman
Artist / Performer
Posts: 7,381
|
Post by Riverman on Apr 8, 2016 0:27:32 GMT
Really excellent thread Cams , thanks for posting! Another reason to regret that I wasn't able to make the RMMGA meeting this year. I must say, the Soundcloud recording was really good. Are you still using the Lyric for recording and live work, and if so how are you finding it?
|
|
francis
C.O.G.
Posts: 2,482
My main instrument is: Whatever I'm building...
|
Post by francis on Apr 8, 2016 5:47:34 GMT
Superb, simply superb
|
|
|
Post by Cams on Apr 8, 2016 8:08:58 GMT
I must say, the Soundcloud recording was really good. Are you still using the Lyric for recording and live work, and if so how are you finding it? I use the Lyric for playing out coupled with a Venue DI. It's a good combo and I get pretty good tone. The boost button is really handy for solos too, but the tuner on the Venue isn't the best. It's still useful to have the mute button there though. For recording I would use mics if I can. It was just that the sound engineer couldn't be bothered I think. I'm pretty sure that was going through a Baggs PADI for that recording.
|
|
Phil Taylor
C.O.G.
Posts: 4,516
Mini-Profile Name Color: 680908
Mini-Profile Text Color: 121311
|
Post by Phil Taylor on Apr 8, 2016 8:24:35 GMT
Really enjoyed that too Cams Phil
|
|